Support native AAC for audio download (m4a) #688

Open
opened 2025-11-09 09:55:59 -06:00 by GiteaMirror · 0 comments
Owner

Originally created by @highbaser on GitHub (Jan 23, 2025).

describe the feature you'd like to see

Under https://cobalt.tools/settings/audio only best, mp3, ogg, wav, opus are supported. All formats except best involve a conversion, which leads to quality loss because of converting a lossy audio track with another lossy codec. Of course users who don't want quality loss can still select "best", but on Youtube this translates to OPUS@48kHz which is isn't a well-supported format by video/audio editors and dedicated (hardware) MP3/MP4 players and gets resampled by Youtube to 48 kHz, while the majority of uploads (e.g.) songs are still sampled @ 44.1 kHz. Youtube still offers a separate AAC audio track under format tag 140 @ ~128 kbit/s and 44.1 kHz. That could be packed into an m4a and offered for download.

Image

additional context

No response

Originally created by @highbaser on GitHub (Jan 23, 2025). ### describe the feature you'd like to see Under https://cobalt.tools/settings/audio only best, mp3, ogg, wav, opus are supported. All formats except best involve a conversion, which leads to quality loss because of converting a lossy audio track with another lossy codec. Of course users who don't want quality loss can still select "best", but on Youtube this translates to OPUS@48kHz which is isn't a well-supported format by video/audio editors and dedicated (hardware) MP3/MP4 players and gets resampled by Youtube to 48 kHz, while the majority of uploads (e.g.) songs are still sampled @ 44.1 kHz. Youtube still offers a separate AAC audio track under format tag 140 @ ~128 kbit/s and 44.1 kHz. That could be packed into an m4a and offered for download. ![Image](https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/a708d523-7819-4d91-a9be-886518de7753) ### additional context _No response_
GiteaMirror added the feature request label 2025-11-09 09:55:59 -06:00
Sign in to join this conversation.