Originally assigned to: @gesellix, @moshloop, @agebhar1, @veggiemonk on GitHub.
It seems to be still unclear when and for what purpose an icon should be used. I'm about to open a new PR updating the pull_request_template.md file.
Currently, we have the following icons with a clear description
🤕 indicates that the project is in beta phase
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
for the following icon, I added a description
💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
following icons need more clarification
🤓 indicates ...
😎 indicates ...
🖥️ indicates ...
Originally created by @ghost on GitHub (Sep 6, 2017).
Original GitHub issue: https://github.com/veggiemonk/awesome-docker/issues/446
Originally assigned to: @gesellix, @moshloop, @agebhar1, @veggiemonk on GitHub.
It seems to be still unclear when and for what purpose an icon should be used. I'm about to open a new PR updating the ```pull_request_template.md``` file.
Currently, we have the following icons with a clear description
- :face_with_head_bandage: indicates that the project is in beta phase
- :heavy_dollar_sign: indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
for the following icon, I added a description
- :skull: indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
following icons need more clarification
- :nerd_face: indicates ...
- :sunglasses: indicates ...
- :desktop_computer: indicates ...
🤓 indicates that the project is meant to be used in a terminal, it's a CLI
😎 indicates that the project is meant to be used in a web browser. it's a web app. (although the sunglasses are really misleading, any better solutions)
🖥️ indicates that the link is a website (not a github project) and it's probably closed source
All of the above can be changed according to use cases. It was just an idea that it would be a bit more joyful to use emojis on the list. You are totally right, if they don't make sense or if they are misleading, they are out!
<!-- gh-comment-id:327702860 -->
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 7, 2017):
@devhkr It's true.
- :nerd_face: indicates that the project is meant to be used in a terminal, it's a CLI
- :sunglasses: indicates that the project is meant to be used in a web browser. it's a web app. (although the sunglasses are really misleading, any better solutions)
- :desktop_computer: indicates that the link is a website (not a github project) and it's probably closed source
All of the above can be changed according to use cases. It was just an idea that it would be a bit more joyful to use emojis on the list. You are totally right, if they don't make sense or if they are misleading, they are out!
@devhkr @veggiemonk Isn't the vast majority of the list CLI? Would it not be better to use them as the exception e.g. a CLI for a native web interface or a Web UI for a native CLI interface?
For web we could use 🌎 o
For CLI we could use 🔤 or 🔡 or ⬛️ or ⌨️
For closed source: 🔑 or 🔒 or 🗝
<!-- gh-comment-id:327713687 -->
@moshloop commented on GitHub (Sep 7, 2017):
@devhkr @veggiemonk Isn't the vast majority of the list CLI? Would it not be better to use them as the exception e.g. a CLI for a native web interface or a Web UI for a native CLI interface?
For web we could use 🌎 o
For CLI we could use 🔤 or 🔡 or ⬛️ or ⌨️
For closed source: 🔑 or 🔒 or 🗝
I would remove the tag for CLI and for web based.... I see already in the PR it's a mess... They don't really add any value since it should be clear in the description what kind of tool it is.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328048867 -->
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
I would remove the tag for CLI and for web based.... I see already in the PR it's a mess... They don't really add any value since it should be clear in the description what kind of tool it is.
@veggiemonk totally agree with you. And I would like to emphasize my comment on tagging. We really should stick to the minimum/essentials where we can definitively put some tags.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328079776 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
@veggiemonk totally agree with you. And I would like to emphasize [my comment](https://github.com/veggiemonk/awesome-docker/issues/393#issuecomment-320203782) on tagging. We really should stick to the minimum/essentials where we can definitively put some tags.
🤕 indicates that the project is in beta phase 💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project 💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
I'm in favour to add the closed source indication by @Moshe-Immerman
🔒 indicates that the project sources are closed
--
So 🤕💲🔒 might be possible 😄
<!-- gh-comment-id:328083835 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
Beside
:face_with_head_bandage: indicates that the project is in beta phase
:heavy_dollar_sign: indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
:skull: indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
I'm in favour to add the closed source indication by @Moshe-Immerman
:lock: indicates that the project sources are closed
--
So :face_with_head_bandage: :heavy_dollar_sign: :lock: might be possible :smile:
It can also happen that a project is work in progress and a 🤕 seems to be the wrong symbol. How about using 🔨 ? It has two meanings, working and fixing. So, it can be used both as a symbol for WIP projects as well as beta projects.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328093277 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
It can also happen that a project is work in progress and a 🤕 seems to be the wrong symbol. How about using 🔨 ? It has two meanings, working and fixing. So, it can be used both as a symbol for WIP projects as well as beta projects.
@devhkr that's a good point 🤕 might be misleading. Beside of 🔨 there is 🛠️ or 🚧 ...
<!-- gh-comment-id:328097279 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
@devhkr that's a good point :face_with_head_bandage: might be misleading. Beside of :hammer: there is :hammer_and_wrench: or :construction: ...
I also had other symbols in mind. But 🔨 looks simple, compared to 🛠 . Like with 💀 and ☠️ .
In addition, 🚧 could only mean work in progress. However, a 🔨 could mean both building and fixing.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328103572 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
@agebhar1 @gesellix
I also had other symbols in mind. But 🔨 looks simple, compared to 🛠 . Like with 💀 and ☠️ .
In addition, 🚧 could only mean work in progress. However, a 🔨 could mean both building and fixing.
🤔 ... that's right, but if we support 'fixing' we should be able to track open tasks/bugs. What did you think?
<!-- gh-comment-id:328107409 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
:thinking: ... that's right, but if we support 'fixing' we should be able to track open tasks/bugs. What did you think?
Ah, I wasn't clear about my previous comment. My point is that if a project is released under beta, there'll be certain bugs to be fixed. So, that's why a 🔨.
What do you mean by tracking open tasks/bugs? We can check the repo by its description. Once a project is released as a stable version, we can remove the symbol then.
Alternatively, we can use 🚧 for work in progress and 🔨 for beta projects. But as I said before, we should stick to the minimum as possible.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328112226 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
Ah, I wasn't clear about my previous comment. My point is that if a project is released under beta, there'll be certain bugs to be fixed. So, that's why a 🔨.
What do you mean by tracking open tasks/bugs? We can check the repo by its description. Once a project is released as a stable version, we can remove the symbol then.
Alternatively, we can use 🚧 for work in progress and 🔨 for beta projects. But as I said before, we should stick to the minimum as possible.
I would also aim at reducing the amount of different symbols. I personally prefer 🚧, mostly due to its resemblance of old websites being "under construction". That would also include "WIP" as well as "Beta". I wouldn't oppose the 🔨, though, it also suggests something like "WIP" to me.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328156845 -->
@gesellix commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
I would also aim at reducing the amount of different symbols. I personally prefer 🚧, mostly due to its resemblance of old websites being "under construction". That would also include "WIP" as well as "Beta". I wouldn't oppose the 🔨, though, it also suggests something like "WIP" to me.
Beta and WIP are roughly the same.. no need to differentiate them as far as I'm concerned
<!-- gh-comment-id:328260586 -->
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
Beta and WIP are roughly the same.. no need to differentiate them as far as I'm concerned
So these two should not change and we will be kept:
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project 💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
Vote by 👍 or 👎
<!-- gh-comment-id:328273934 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
So these two should not change and we will be kept:
:heavy_dollar_sign: indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
:skull: indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
**Vote** by :+1: or :-1:
<!-- gh-comment-id:328273945 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
:face_with_head_bandage: Beta/WIP should be replaced by
:construction: indicates that the project is in beta phase
**Vote** by :+1:
<!-- gh-comment-id:328274057 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
:face_with_head_bandage: Beta/WIP should be replaced by
:hammer: indicates that the project is in beta phase
**Vote** by :+1:
<!-- gh-comment-id:328274121 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
I suggest to add closed source
:lock: indicates that the project sources are closed
**Vote** by :+1: or :-1:
We already have a 💲 for commercial tools which are considered as closed source projects. And as @veggiemonk also suggested that 🖥️ icon is for websites (not a GitHub project page) which are probably considered as closed source projects as well. We don't need the 🔒 icon then. What do you think?
<!-- gh-comment-id:328288546 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
We already have a :heavy_dollar_sign: for commercial tools which are considered as closed source projects. And as @veggiemonk also suggested that :desktop_computer: icon is for websites (not a GitHub project page) which are probably considered as closed source projects as well. We don't need the :lock: icon then. What do you think?
Ok, you convinced me that we should use 🚧 tag for WIP/Beta projects 😄
But still not convinced by the closed source one.
Can you name me please an example which project(s) could have such a tag?
UPDATE: Just a quick additional remark on the 🔒. This icon also reminds me about security. Wherever I visit a project/web page, I see this when it is referred as a secure application/website.
Even if we explain that it stands for closed source, but the majority of people have always the security in mind. What do you think?
<!-- gh-comment-id:328300468 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
Ok, you convinced me that we should use :construction: tag for WIP/Beta projects :smile:
But still not convinced by the closed source one.
Can you name me please an example which project(s) could have such a tag?
UPDATE: Just a quick additional remark on the :lock:. This icon also reminds me about security. Wherever I visit a project/web page, I see this when it is referred as a secure application/website.
Even if we explain that it stands for closed source, but the majority of people have always the security in mind. What do you think?
Good point @devhkr the symbol 🔒 is the same as in web browser if https is used with a valid certificate. Slack use the symbol for private channels ... so maybe we skip 'closed source' for the moment.
<!-- gh-comment-id:328363531 -->
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 10, 2017):
Good point @devhkr the symbol :lock: is the same as in web browser if https is used with a valid certificate. Slack use the symbol for private channels ... so maybe we skip 'closed source' for the moment.
I realized that lately. Sorry about that. Ok, we have then
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project 🚧 indicates that the project is in the work in progress/beta phase 💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
I'll open a new PR updating the 'README.md' and the 'pull_request_template.md'.
Thanks for your feedback guys and have a nice day 😃
BTW, now 8,000 🌟
<!-- gh-comment-id:328460386 -->
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 11, 2017):
I realized that lately. Sorry about that. Ok, we have then
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
🚧 indicates that the project is in the work in progress/beta phase
💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
I'll open a new PR updating the 'README.md' and the 'pull_request_template.md'.
Thanks for your feedback guys and have a nice day 😃
BTW, now 8,000 🌟
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
Originally created by @ghost on GitHub (Sep 6, 2017).
Original GitHub issue: https://github.com/veggiemonk/awesome-docker/issues/446
Originally assigned to: @gesellix, @moshloop, @agebhar1, @veggiemonk on GitHub.
It seems to be still unclear when and for what purpose an icon should be used. I'm about to open a new PR updating the
pull_request_template.mdfile.Currently, we have the following icons with a clear description
for the following icon, I added a description
following icons need more clarification
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 7, 2017):
@devhkr It's true.
All of the above can be changed according to use cases. It was just an idea that it would be a bit more joyful to use emojis on the list. You are totally right, if they don't make sense or if they are misleading, they are out!
@moshloop commented on GitHub (Sep 7, 2017):
@devhkr @veggiemonk Isn't the vast majority of the list CLI? Would it not be better to use them as the exception e.g. a CLI for a native web interface or a Web UI for a native CLI interface?
For web we could use 🌎 o
For CLI we could use 🔤 or 🔡 or ⬛️ or ⌨️
For closed source: 🔑 or 🔒 or 🗝
@gesellix commented on GitHub (Sep 7, 2017):
For web/link: 🔗
For CLI: 🤖
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
I would remove the tag for CLI and for web based.... I see already in the PR it's a mess... They don't really add any value since it should be clear in the description what kind of tool it is.
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
@veggiemonk totally agree with you. And I would like to emphasize my comment on tagging. We really should stick to the minimum/essentials where we can definitively put some tags.
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
Beside
🤕 indicates that the project is in beta phase
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
I'm in favour to add the closed source indication by @Moshe-Immerman
🔒 indicates that the project sources are closed
--
So 🤕 💲 🔒 might be possible 😄
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
It can also happen that a project is work in progress and a 🤕 seems to be the wrong symbol. How about using 🔨 ? It has two meanings, working and fixing. So, it can be used both as a symbol for WIP projects as well as beta projects.
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
@devhkr that's a good point 🤕 might be misleading. Beside of 🔨 there is 🛠️ or 🚧 ...
@gesellix commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
Nice, I would prefer 🚧 or 🔨.
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
@agebhar1 @gesellix
I also had other symbols in mind. But 🔨 looks simple, compared to 🛠 . Like with 💀 and ☠️ .
In addition, 🚧 could only mean work in progress. However, a 🔨 could mean both building and fixing.
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
🤔 ... that's right, but if we support 'fixing' we should be able to track open tasks/bugs. What did you think?
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
Ah, I wasn't clear about my previous comment. My point is that if a project is released under beta, there'll be certain bugs to be fixed. So, that's why a 🔨.
What do you mean by tracking open tasks/bugs? We can check the repo by its description. Once a project is released as a stable version, we can remove the symbol then.
Alternatively, we can use 🚧 for work in progress and 🔨 for beta projects. But as I said before, we should stick to the minimum as possible.
@gesellix commented on GitHub (Sep 8, 2017):
I would also aim at reducing the amount of different symbols. I personally prefer 🚧, mostly due to its resemblance of old websites being "under construction". That would also include "WIP" as well as "Beta". I wouldn't oppose the 🔨, though, it also suggests something like "WIP" to me.
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
👍 for 🚧
@veggiemonk commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
Beta and WIP are roughly the same.. no need to differentiate them as far as I'm concerned
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
So these two should not change and we will be kept:
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
Vote by 👍 or 👎
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
🤕 Beta/WIP should be replaced by
🚧 indicates that the project is in beta phase
Vote by 👍
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
🤕 Beta/WIP should be replaced by
🔨 indicates that the project is in beta phase
Vote by 👍
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
I suggest to add closed source
🔒 indicates that the project sources are closed
Vote by 👍 or 👎
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
We already have a 💲 for commercial tools which are considered as closed source projects. And as @veggiemonk also suggested that 🖥️ icon is for websites (not a GitHub project page) which are probably considered as closed source projects as well. We don't need the 🔒 icon then. What do you think?
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 9, 2017):
Ok, you convinced me that we should use 🚧 tag for WIP/Beta projects 😄
But still not convinced by the closed source one.
Can you name me please an example which project(s) could have such a tag?
UPDATE: Just a quick additional remark on the 🔒. This icon also reminds me about security. Wherever I visit a project/web page, I see this when it is referred as a secure application/website.
Even if we explain that it stands for closed source, but the majority of people have always the security in mind. What do you think?
@agebhar1 commented on GitHub (Sep 10, 2017):
Good point @devhkr the symbol 🔒 is the same as in web browser if https is used with a valid certificate. Slack use the symbol for private channels ... so maybe we skip 'closed source' for the moment.
@ghost commented on GitHub (Sep 11, 2017):
I realized that lately. Sorry about that. Ok, we have then
💲 indicates if one needs a paying subscription to use the project
🚧 indicates that the project is in the work in progress/beta phase
💀 indicates that the project is obsolete, but still worth mentioning it
I'll open a new PR updating the 'README.md' and the 'pull_request_template.md'.
Thanks for your feedback guys and have a nice day 😃
BTW, now 8,000 🌟